With our list of the 30 Butterfinger desserts for dessert lovers, you’re about to go on a tasty trip through the world of sweets. If you like the famous Butterfinger candy bar, you’ll love these dishes.

There’s a sweet treat for every taste, from rich and gooey brownies to creamy cheesecakes, chewy cookies to delicious ice cream cakes. We’ve put the well-known tastes of Butterfingers into every delicious thing we’ve made.

Whether you’re having a party or just want to treat yourself to something sweet, these desserts will make your mouth water and leave you wanting more.

So let’s dive into the world of buttery, peanut-buttery goodness and find the magic in every bite of Butterfinger.

Table of Contents

Butterfinger desserts for dessert lovers

All dessert fans, listen up! Get ready to satisfy your sweet tooth with Butterfinger desserts that are hard to resist.

Imagine delicious Butterfinger brownie layers with a creamy crunch on top, dreamy cheesecakes with Butterfinger pieces on top, and peanut butter ice cream with caramel and Butterfinger pieces mixed in.

Dive into a trifle heaven, make easy Butterfinger bites that don’t even need to be baked, or enjoy warm, gooey Butterfinger-stuffed cookies.

In every bite of these delicious treats, you can taste sweet, crunchy, and heavenly flavors. Your dreams about dessert just got a lot sweeter.

1. Butterfinger Brownie Delight

Our Butterfinger Brownie Delight takes indulgence to a whole new level. Imagine biting into fudgy brownies that are layered with chunks of Butterfinger.

The mix of chocolate and peanut butter flavors would be hard to avoid. Each bite has a variety of textures, from the smooth brownie base to the crispy, buttery bits that give it its signature crunch.

This treat is a celebration of contrasts, with a drizzle of chocolate and a sprinkle of crushed Butterfingers on top. Don’t miss out on the chance to see what happens when chocolate and peanut butter meet.

2. Butterf i nger Cheesecake

With our Butterfinger Cheesecake, you’re in for a slice of pure luxury. This cheesecake is creamy and smooth as silk.

It has a buttery graham cracker crust that goes well with the rich peanut butter undertones. Every spoonful has pieces of Butterfinger that give it a wonderful crunch and a burst of sweetness.

No matter if you love cheesecake or Butterfingers, this dessert is a match made in treat heaven. With just one bite, you’ll know why this cheesecake is so good.

3. Butterfinger Chocolate Chip Cookies

Our Butterfinger Chocolate Chip Cookies will take your cookie game to the next level. Imagine the comfort of a warm chocolate chip cookie, but with a twist that makes it hard to say no.

There are a lot of chopped Butterfingers in these cookies, making a mix of flavors that dance on your taste buds.

The cookies are just the right amount of chewy and crunchy, so each bite is a new texture treat. With a glass of milk in your hand, you’re in for a treat that brings back memories and gives you a taste of something new.

4. Butterfinger Ice Cream Cake

Our Butterfinger Ice Cream Cake will help you beat the heat and please your sweet tooth.

Layers of smooth vanilla ice cream and rich chocolate ice cream are woven together with a peanut butter string and pieces of Butterfinger. What happened? A frozen work of art with a symphony of different tastes and textures.

From the first spoonful to the last, you’ll feel the thrill of smooth ice cream, the fun crunch of Butterfingers, and the magic of a dessert that captures the essence of pleasure.

5. Peanut Butter Butterfinger Bars

The Peanut Butter Butterfinger Bars are a sweet treat where peanut butter is the main attraction.

Crushed Butterfingers are sprinkled all over a thick layer of peanut butter filling. The smooth peanut butter and crunchy Butterfingers make a great contrast.

The chocolate drizzle on top of these bars makes them a masterpiece of sweet harmony.

Each bite is a tribute to the tastes we loved as kids, reimagined as an adult treat that’s hard to say no to.

6. Butterfinger Cupcake Extravaganza

Our Butterfinger Cupcake Extravaganza takes the taste of cupcakes to a whole new level.

A large swirl of peanut butter frosting on top of moist chocolate cupcakes is a match made in dessert heaven. But the real magic is inside each cupcake, where a Butterfinger is hidden like a prize.

Every time you take a bite, you’ll be excited to find that delicious crunch that goes so well with the smooth filling. It’s not just a cupcake; it’s a party of tastes that will make you want more.

7. Buttery Butterfinger Blondies

With our Buttery Butterfinger Blondies, blondies get a rich twist. These bars are a beauty of buttery goodness.

They are soft and chewy and can’t be stopped from eating. Each bite has big chunks of Butterfinger and a symphony of tastes and textures that will blow your mind.

The gentle caramel notes of the blondies go well with the sweet and salty flavors of the Butterfinger, making a treat that is as beautiful as it is tasty.

8. Butterfinger Tiramisu

With our Butterfinger Tiramisu, you’ll be taken away to dessert heaven. Layers of thin Ladyfinger cookies are soaked in coffee and topped with a smooth mascarpone cream that has the flavor of Butterfinger mixed in.

The result is a treat that is both elegant and fun. The classic flavors of tiramisu are beautifully complemented by the buttery crunch of Butterfingers.

Each bite takes you on a trip through layers of taste and texture. It’s a luxurious experience that you can’t say no to.

9. Butterfinger Popcorn

With our Butterfinger Popcorn, snacking gets even more exciting. Imagine if buttery popcorn and the tempting crunch of Butterfingers got together to make the best candy ever.

Every kernel is covered in a delicious peanut butter caramel, and crushed Butterfinger bits are sprinkled on top. The result is a blend of sweet and salty tastes that will make you want more.

This popcorn is the ultimate crowd-pleaser and will make your taste buds dance, whether you’re having a movie night or a party.

10. Butterfinger Stuffed Donuts

With our Butterfinger Stuffed Donuts, a donut becomes a work of art. Imagine donuts that are as soft as pillows and filled with a rich and delicious Butterfinger filling.

When you take a bite, the sweet dough, creamy peanut butter, and crunchy candy bits all come together in a burst of flavor. With a smooth chocolate glaze and crushed Butterfingers on top, these donuts look and taste great and will make you want more.

Prepare to change the way you think about donuts and taste the magic of Butterfinger in every bite.

11. Velvety Butterfinger Triffles

Experience dessert elegance like never before with our Velvety Butterfinger Triffles.

This treat is a mix of two opposites: light and airy Triffles and the irresistible crunch of Butterfingers.

Each spoonful has just the right amount of creamy texture and sweet indulgence, making this a treat that is both elegant and comforting.

With crushed Butterfingers sprinkled on top, you’ll enjoy every bite of this luxurious treat.

12. Butterfingers Oatmeal Cookies

Our Butterfinger Oatmeal Cookies will take your cookie jar to the next level.

In these cookies, hearty oats and the delicious crunch of Butterfingers come together in a way that is both healthy and sweet. What happened? A chewy, crunchy, and very delicious cookie.

With every bite, you’ll taste the comforting flavors of oatmeal and the fun flavors of Butterfinger, making a treat that’s great for cozy times and happy gatherings.

13. Butterfinger Caramel Brownies

Unleash your sweet tooth with our Butterfinger Caramel Brownies. Enjoy the luxury of fudgy brownies topped with a layer of gooey caramel that has Butterfinger pieces in it.

When you bite into this beauty, you’ll get a rush from the smooth caramel, the richness of the brownie, and the crunch of the candy.

It has a lot of different tastes that will make you want more.

14. Frozen Butterfinger Pie

With our Frozen Butterfinger Pie, you can relax in style. A buttery graham cracker crust holds a peanut butter center with chunks of Butterfinger that is smooth and velvety.

This frozen treat is both creamy and refreshing, with tastes that work well together and dance on your tongue.

Each slice is a trip through layers of cold delight, topped with whipped cream and crushed Butterfingers.

15. Butterfinger Banana Bread

Banana bread gets a delectable upgrade with our Butterfinger Banana Bread.

This banana bread is soft and tasty, and it has the irresistible crunch of Butterfingers on top, making it a treat that is both cozy and exciting.

You can taste the sweetness of ripe bananas and the fun contrast of candy bits in every bite. You can eat it warm with coffee or as a tasty snack at any time of day.

16. Butterscotch Butterfinger Pudding

Butterscotch Butterfinger Pudding will wrap you in a soft hug. This dessert is a celebration of the rich tastes of butterscotch, along with the famous crunch of Butterfingers.

Each bite is a trip through creamy pudding and crunchy bits, making this a treat that is both familiar and new.

This pudding is a must-try if you like butterscotch or just like the thrill of different tastes.

17. Butterfinger Crumble Bars

With our Butterfinger Crumble Bars, you can enjoy the joy of crunchy goodness.

A layer of delicious caramel and a lot of Butterfinger pieces go on top of a base of buttery shortbread.

When you bite into one of these bars, you’ll taste how well the buttery crust, the gooey caramel, and the fun crunch all work together. With every bite, you’ll find a new taste and texture that will make you love this dessert even more.

18. Butterfinger Coffee Affogato

Our Butterfinger Coffee Affogato will take your coffee break to the next level. Rich, strong coffee is poured over vanilla ice cream that is soft and smooth and has crushed Butterfingers on top.

The result is a dessert-drink creation that combines the warmth of coffee with the coolness of ice cream and the fun crunch of candy.

It’s the perfect way to enjoy a moment of decadence and a symphony of tastes in every spoonful.

19. Butterfinger Pancake Stack

Our Butterfinger Pancake Stack is the perfect way to start your day.

When you layer fluffy pancakes with peanut butter sauce and put crushed Butterfingers on top, you get a breakfast that is both comforting and exciting.

Each bite has a mix of soft pancakes, smooth peanut butter, and the crunch that makes Butterfingers famous.

It’s a tasty breakfast treat that will get you ready to get up and go.

20. Butterfinger Rice Pudding

With our Butterfinger Rice Pudding, you’ll remember how good rice pudding is. peanut butter flavor is mixed into creamy rice pudding, and chunks of Butterfinger candy add a fun crunch.

This dish takes you on a trip through familiar tastes and new textures to make a treat that is both old and new.

This rice pudding will become your new favorite dessert, whether you like it hot or cold.

21. Chocolate Dipped Butterfinger Bites

With our Chocolate Dipped Butterfinger Bites, you can feel the thrill of perfection dipped in chocolate.

Butterfinger pieces are covered in smooth chocolate to make a treat that is both beautiful and decadent.

Every bite is a symphony of tastes, from the rich chocolate covering to the buttery crunch of the candy inside.

These bites are a fun way to explore differences, whether you’re treating yourself or trying to wow your guests.

22. Butterfinger Cream Pie

With our Butterfinger Cream Pie, you can taste the essence of happiness.

A flaky pie shell holds a smooth peanut butter filling that is topped with whipped cream and crushed Butterfingers.

Every bite is a party of tastes, from the creaminess of the peanut butter to the sweetness of the candy.

Whether you’re having a party or just want to treat yourself to something sweet, this pie is a bit of dessert heaven.

23. Butterfinger Energy Bites

Our Butterfinger Energy Bites will give you a burst of taste and energy to get you through the day.

These bites are the right combination of healthy ingredients like oats, peanut butter, and honey with the fun crunch of Butterfinger.

Whether you need a quick pick-me-up or a treat after a workout, these energy bites will fill your cravings and keep you going with a fun twist.

24. Butterfinger Swirl Cheesecake Brownies

With our Butterfinger Swirl Cheesecake Brownies, you can find balance in a dessert.

Fudgy brownies and smooth cheesecake are swirled together to make a treat that is both beautiful and delicious.

Each bite, which is topped with crushed Butterfingers, is a symphony of tastes and textures that will blow your mind.

It’s a sweet treat that’s meant to be savored slowly and shared with people who know how to treat themselves well.

25. Buttermilk Waffles with Butterfinger Syrup

Our Buttermilk Waffles with Butterfinger Syrup will take your waffle game to the next level.

Crispy waffles are topped with a delicious peanut butter syrup that tastes like Butterfinger candies.

As you pour the syrup over the waffles, you’ll see the magic happen as it runs down the crevices. With each bite, you’ll get the right amount of crunchy waffles, smooth syrup, and crunchy candy.

It’s an amazing way to have breakfast.

26. Butterfinger Caramel Dip

With our Butterfinger Caramel Dip, you can dive into sweetness. This delicious dip is a mix of rich caramel and the fun crunch of Butterfingers.

Whether you’re dipping apple slices, pretzels, or your favorite cookies, each bite has the perfect mix of soft and crunchy.

This dip shows how much fun simple things can be and how magical it can be to mix old favorites in new and exciting ways.

27. Butterfinger Layered Parfait

Our Butterfinger Layered Parfait is full of layers of deliciousness. Creamy vanilla yogurt, peanut butter sauce, and big chunks of Butterfinger come together to make a dessert that is both light and rich.

Each spoonful is a trip through different textures and flavors that work well together, making a parfait that looks as good as it tastes.

This dessert is a real show-stopper, whether you want to treat yourself or wow your guests.

28. Butterfinger S’mores Bars

With our Butterfinger S’mores Bars, you can enjoy the fun of campfire snacks.

There are layers of a buttery graham cracker crust and a smooth chocolate filling with marshmallows and Butterfinger bits.

With every bite, you’ll feel nostalgic for s’mores, which are made even better by the crunchy candy.

Whether you’re cooking marshmallows over an open flame or just want to feel like you’re at a campfire, these bars are a great way to feel like you’re on an outdoor adventure.

29. Butterfinger Cinnamon Rolls

Our Butterfinger Cinnamon Rolls are a great way to start your day because they are so tasty.

Cinnamon, sugar, and Butterfingers are mixed with pillowy soft rolls to make a breakfast treat that is both comfortable and exciting.

The cinnamon roll gets a fun new twist from the creamy peanut butter and the fun crunch of candy.

These rolls are a party of tastes that will make your taste buds dance, whether you eat them right out of the oven or as a noon snack.

30. Butterfinger Rice Krispie Squares

With our Butterfinger Rice Krispie Squares, you can feel like a kid again.

Crispy rice cereal melted marshmallows, and a lot of Butterfingers come together to make a treat that is both sticky and crunchy.

Each square is a fun dance of different textures, taking you on a trip through sticky marshmallows and the classic crunch of candy.

It’s a dessert that will take you back in time, but you can still enjoy the exciting tastes of grown-up food.

Why You Should Eat Desserts Before Dinner? 21 Reasons

21 Healthy Desserts After Dinner That Satisfies Your Cravings

Summary

With these 30 Butterfinger desserts for dessert lovers, you have access to a world of taste and fun.

Each creation shows off the popular Butterfinger candy in a new and delightful way, from sweet and rich to light and refreshing.

So, whether you’re a seasoned dessert lover or just like trying out new flavors, these recipes are your ticket to a world of sweet pleasure.